Dufferin Mutual Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Dufferin Mutual Insurance
We offer the standard Ontario automobile owners policy as written by our provincial government. There are a number of discounts available to you if you meet the qualifications. We also allow for a discount if your home, farm or contents are insured with our company. Dufferin Mutual has packaged it's products to allow us to offer choices to meet the needs of your home and you.

We consider each home individually, we look at the age of your home, it's location, type of construction and whether any upgrades have been made to the wiring, plumbing, heating or roof. This organization was founded in 1895 as a farm mutual and remains a true 'mutual' today, owned entirely by it's policyholders, The headquarters are still in Shelburne, in the heart of the district it serves.
Services
This organization was founded in 1895 as a farm mutual and remains a true 'mutual' today, owned entirely by it's policyholders, The headquarters are still in Shelburne, in the heart of the district it serves. Things have changed in the last 100 years, and so has Dufferin Mutual. We are a fully licensed multi-line insurer offering protection for property, automobile, and liability insurance to over 5000 policyholders.
We the Directors, Management and Staff of the Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company are proud to be part of the insurance industry, and we are proud of the professionalism we strive to display in each interaction with people from both within and outside our industry.

We are committed to a strict obligation of providing the best possible service to our policyholders, brokers, claimants and others with whom we come in contact, while always keeping in mind the best interests of all our insureds.We believe that all our interactions must be both fair and honest. We pledge to avoid any false, misleading or misrepresentation of our policies or our services.
Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company has packaged it's products to allow us to offer choices to meet all your insurance needs. Whether it be your home, auto, farm or business we understand your needs and have developed products to fill them. Ask our team of experienced brokers to explain how each of these packages and categories can fully benefit you.
Dufferin Mutual has packaged it's products to allow us to offer choices to meet the needs of your home and you. We consider each home individually, we look at the age of your home, it's location, type of construction and whether any upgrades have been made to the wiring, plumbing, heating or roof. Our experienced and qualified team of brokers will then establish a value to replace your home and explain the options available to you.
Dufferin Mutual Insurance Company stakes its reputation on settling claims quickly and fairly. As a policyholder of this company, you can be assured that when mishap occurs we will be there right beside you to help pick up the pieces. You will also have the piece of mind knowing that your mutual has the financial strength and ability to look after you.
Reviews (3)
Robert Cryer
Robert Cryer
Oct 11, 2020
Report
Just a terrible agency! They take your money but their policy is to ALWAYS deny a claim and wait until you sue. Never, NEVER take out a policy to rent your house. After increasing the premium costs significantly, they could not even think of one thing that the policy would cover. Our new agency is costing one third less. People, shop around. There ARE better options
Poppy Diarrah Head Skanka
Poppy Diarrah Head Skanka
Jun 05, 2020
Report
One claim since 1981 and they dropped us over a claim for approximately 3500$.
Ian F.
Ian F.
Jan 30, 2020
Report
I have 4 houses insured with this company. Cheap price and cheap service. This company will do everything in their power to deny a claim and IF they do pay out, they will drop you. Million of dollars insurance and $10,000 claim and they dropped me.
Also have a third party company witness their adjuster guessing at the cause of a water damage claim. They later called in a building engineer that ALSO guessed at the cause which we later found wrong when we gutted the basement. Asked for a review at that time and we hear crickets.
This company will definately not be there when you need them.