With strong roots in the north end of St. Catharines, the owners of Pie Guys first came together to open up a pizzeria that held true to their authentic Italian family recipes and love of delicious food.
Once Pie Guys on the corner of Linwell and Vine established itself as the neighbourhood 'go to' for pizza and wings, it quickly became a local customer favourite for their in house, hand tossed dough and homemade pizza and marinara sauces, meatballs and salad dressings.After a few years and several 'Best Pizza of the Year' awards from the city of St. Catharines, it was time to branch out!
Once Pie Guys on the corner of Linwell and Vine established itself as the neighbourhood 'go to' for pizza and wings, it quickly became a local customer favourite for their in house, hand tossed dough and homemade pizza and marinara sauces, meatballs and salad dressings.After a few years and several 'Best Pizza of the Year' awards from the city of St. Catharines, it was time to branch out!
Services
Four hearty homemade meatballs in our house marinara, topped with parmesan and mozzarelaa cheese. Served with freshly toasted garlic bread. 7 Jumbo shrimp baked in a white wine & garlic butter sauce with feta, mozzarella and asiago cheese. Served with garlic toast points. Lettuce, red onions, grape tomatoes, feta cheese, kalamata olives, with our homemade vinaigrette dressing.
Reviews (20)
Ross Allen
Jan 24, 2022
Report
Jo Ey
Dec 20, 2021
Report
I've always liked Pie Guys Pizza. The staff is pleasant and it top of the line pizza. However it has gone down hill and the prices have sky rocketed. I've reduced my times of ordering there due to prices and not being ready on time mostly. I had just ordered another pizza there and was told 30 mins. I got there in 30 mins and was told "it will just be a few more minutes" and to wait in my car. I proceeded to wait for another 31 mins. Clearly the pizza wasn't even put in oven when I was told a few
more minutes. I'm not one to complain or make scene. (maybe I should have) but I dont like confrontation
more minutes. I'm not one to complain or make scene. (maybe I should have) but I dont like confrontation
Mandy Wright
Dec 11, 2021
Report
Bought 3lbs of chicken wings tonight. The bag was so light (even with the celery, carrots and dip), that I immediately went home and weighed the portions. I understand they may be weighed in a raw state, but… when you lose over half the weight, and only end up with 7 wings per portion, that was really off-putting. Unfortunately they were dry too so felt a bit ripped off for almost $40 after tax. I don't want to go as far as saying not to recommend trying them (taste was good), but Facebook doesn't give an in between option.
Carly Megan
Dec 02, 2021
Report
Anita Engelage
Nov 10, 2021
Report
Rrr Lll
Sep 23, 2021
Report
Pizza Wings steak subs all delicious....... I'm 61 years old it's the best wings pizza and steak sub I've ever had in my entire life so I contacted the owner........
He said it will not compromise on the ingredients.......
Amazing absolutely amazing food.......... Thanks pie guys you'll be seeing a lot of me
👍🏼👍🏼
He said it will not compromise on the ingredients.......
Amazing absolutely amazing food.......... Thanks pie guys you'll be seeing a lot of me
👍🏼👍🏼
Don Bartley
Sep 22, 2021
Report
Great pizza and wings unfortunately they just can’t seem to figure out the busy times. If it’s going to be an hour and a half then just say so. The most infuriating thing is being told 45 minutes then wait in the parking lot another 45 minutes. Would happily wait in the comfort of my home until it’s actually ready. Spoke to many people in the parking lot while waiting and all said the same thing. We’re done as it’s happened too many times. Sorry guys, figure it out and I’m sure you’ll be the pizza place in town. Bye bye
Hi Mom
Sep 20, 2021
Report
Disappointed to say the slices have gotten smaller, but the prices certainly haven’t. this lunch cost $9
edit- new ownership or something? given the owner’s response, not recognizing a single face from before the pandemic, service being slow and unfriendly, and the staff literally purchased and made a pizza for themselves before my slice was ready... so not what it used to be.
edit- new ownership or something? given the owner’s response, not recognizing a single face from before the pandemic, service being slow and unfriendly, and the staff literally purchased and made a pizza for themselves before my slice was ready... so not what it used to be.
Savan Harsh
Sep 18, 2021
Report
Mel V.
Sep 03, 2021
Report
We used to love this place! Keep trying hoping it will be better but it’s just more disappointing each time. 4 times now we’ve ordered bacon on the garlic bread and it comes with none. We made a note this time politely asking to make sure they add it. They did, however the garlic bread was burnt.. like black. Not sure how anyone can look at that and be ok sending it out! The wings are over cooked and hardly any sauce. The pizza is extremely greasy. Guess it’s time to find a new pizza place now :(
Tyler Costa
Jul 11, 2021
Report
I used to order from here all the time, food was great, best pizza around and I recommended it to a lot of people. Lately it’s been really bad, the pizza has been undercooked a few times, cheese isn’t melted etc. When I called to complain (not expecting a new pizza) they offered me my same order again for free next time and put that on file. When I called to get it, they said it didn’t exist. So we started just ordering wings instead of pizza, which was also really great at first. Now they are half the size than before, overcooked to the point I can’t get the meat off the bone. Great price
Wissam Salame
Jul 10, 2021
Report
I am a restaurant owner and today was my day off . My kids wanted pizza for lunch . I was passing by and decided to go in . First time trying this place . I was impressed with the service and how good the pizza was . I ordered one cheese and one with some topping. I can say best pizza I have ever had . I didn’t tip cause I need to know that the food is good . Next time you ladies are getting a very good tip from me . I can’t thank you enough. Keep up the good work
Bradislav Gordonov
May 25, 2021
Report
Such a bummer. The pizza tastes great, especially from Linwell. Bit of a dip to the Mc in quality. The online ordering system sucks. Good luck splitting halves for toppings. Wasted 15-20 mins attempting multiple orders. No Bueno. Order lost, Pizza Hut on the way, easy online for them. The pizza is top notch though, like best in the city. Just a mega hassle to order if you are short on patience.
Nicole Altieri
May 18, 2021
Report
Ted C.
May 10, 2019
Report
Daniella F.
Apr 22, 2019
Report
Clara L.
Mar 27, 2019
Report
Jack E.
Apr 07, 2018
Report
First time here live in north end and love the pizza and wings at the scott street location. The pizza and wings are the same here very decent as well many drink specials which is nice. My wife of course orders something on the menu which was not quite as good as the pizza cause you know we are at PIE GUYS PIZZERIA and why not order a chicken parmesan sub . Footnote chicken parmesan and the sub version is her favourite food and I've seen many a version of this item over the years . but this one isn't even close to what one would expect i will leave a couple of photos in hope they change
Nina S.
Aug 02, 2017
Report
I have enjoyed many pizzas and the amazing service from the Linwell location, but I live closer to the MacTurnbull location so I ordered from there tonight. I received my pizza an hour and a half after ordering it. It was luke warm. When I called after an hour and 15 to ask if my order had been forgotten I was met with excuses about the delivery company and a bit of attitude. I was going to bring the pizzas back to them for my money back, but I'm so angry that it isn't worth the stress. Lesson learned.
Roy J.
Apr 09, 2017
Report
Excellent food, nice atmosphere, friendly and attentive staff. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a must try. I'm not one for "burn-your-mouth-off" spice, but this is made just right. We've been a few times if we had a desire for pizza and we're passing through, but if we lived in the area it would definitely be my favourite spot for pizza.
