PIC 'N' PAY SHOES is a family owned shoe store that has been in business for over 60 years. The "Unger" family has owned it for just over 30 years. In 2008, Randy and Shannon Unger purchased the business from Randy's parents. Our staff has many years of experience with fitting footwear! Customer service is a very high priority for us.

We carry sizes up to mens 18 and ladies up to size 11, children's sizes from 4 infant to 7 youth. Randy & Shannon, together with our staff Earl, Mary, Darlene, Madeleine, Shaylene, Liz, Tiffany & Nicole would love to help you find all your footwear needs!

Website Update

Reviews (8)

Write a Review

Deanne Dandeneau

Nov 09, 2021

Report

I got a pair of bluntstones and they’re where too small sadly so I went back and they gave me a new pair of boots in the right size:)) the guy that helped me was awesome he’s always so friendly!!, thank you so much!!!!:)))

Kris Engel

Oct 15, 2021

Report

Very helpful/friendly staff who were able to help me out with a hilarious shoe disaster at an affordable price (the soles of my shoes actually came off, and they were able to recommend a shoe glue that was strong enough to get them up and running again for an upcoming wedding!)

Caleb Sterzer

Aug 22, 2021

Report

Had a great experience would recommend staff member was amazing, could not find a pair of shoes that worked for me but they recommended an insole that has been amazing so far.

Robert Erstelle

Jul 24, 2021

Report

Also able to find what we want, nice facilities, great selection, great prices, good customer service.

Damjjm

Jul 10, 2021

Report

Very friendly and knowledgeable, every size we needed, my son is a size 15 and no problems finding footwear for all of us!

Rickey Penner

Dec 11, 2020

Report

Great service! Listened to my needs and provided me with various options of footwear with various price points. I highly recommend you visit, if you're in need of good quality footwear.

R. Barkman

Sep 24, 2020

Report

Genuine and Great, Personalized customer service that is second to none in the line of footwear and accessories! Very good selection of products. Keep up the good work y'all!

Angela Storey

Dec 06, 2019

Report

I support some elderly people who need help finding boots, shoes and slippers. The staff at pic-n-pay shoes are always helpful. They happily measure their feet and bring them many options to try on until we find the exactly what they need. Great customer service.

Pic-N-Pay Shoes