Ayr Farmers' Mutual Insurance
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Ayr Farmers' Mutual Insurance
Insurance for your home, cottage, condominium, rental property, including marine and watercraft coverage. Insurance for poultry, grain, dairy, equine, hog and hobby farm operations, including rural homes with acreage. Specialized insurance coverage for contractors, offices, retail, churches, residential rentals and home-based businesses.

Through sound financial risk management practices, the Board of Directors monitors and ensures the Company is financially secure to enhance growth, sustain inflation, and most importantly, meet the liabilities the Company incurs through losses. When these measures are obtained, combined with the results of a successful year, the Board of Directors may declare a refund of premiums to its qualifying members.
Services
As an Ontario Mutual, we believe in being there for our neighbors and lending a hand when it matters most. We believe in building better and stronger communities. We believe that our small company can provide better service. We invest in local sports teams, events, community projects, and other things that we hold dear.
For over 125 years, our purpose has been simple and clear: Ayr Farmers Mutual exists for our Policyholders. We were created out of the need to protect our communities from devastating losses caused by fire. Our values guide our actions, as they have since 1893. Our knowledgeable and caring team members have helped thousands of people find peace of mind by aligning our Policyholders with products and services created to meet their insurance needs.
We were created out of a necessity to serve our community. A small group of farmers believed in helping each other protect against devastating fire losses. That time-honoured tradition of neighbour helping neighbour was envisioned 125 years ago and the same values remain today. We are passionate about building strong, safe communities and will continue to do so for years to come.
Reviews (14)
Imabong Akpan
Imabong Akpan
Jan 23, 2022
Report
You are one in a million, best among many, most trusted, I almost gave up on trading then I met through a friend, Allen martha the most trusted trading expert who helped the life of my family and I, I also recommended her to my friends and family member who also have become financially successful thanks to you ma'am, I have lost a lot but you gave… me hope and faith that forex and binary trade could help, and you proved it when I invested just $500 and earned $7,000 in just a week, since then it has been profit after profit all week, I am arguing the entire public to invest and be financially
Karri Montgomery
Karri Montgomery
Jan 19, 2022
Report
Positive: Quality, Responsiveness
We are new customers to Ayr, and unfortunately needed to make a major claim. Our broker Kyle has been nothing but awesome in being available as a touch point for us, and our claims person has been very helpful and is always fast to respond. Very happy with our experience with them.
Aaron Gorlick
Aaron Gorlick
Nov 21, 2021
Report
I missed a quarterly payment when my wife’s disability demanding more of my time for my 3 small children. Martin was always kind and helpful, but unfortunately the company he works for doesn’t recognize people with disabilities and their families as needing special consideration on occasion.
Then my father passed away, and I assisted on his death bed, further distracted from the finances. The money was in the bank! I just didn’t think of paying it with everything else on my mind.
Does Ayr Mutual care? No. They cancelled my insurance policy, on a century home. It will be very difficult to
Steph Vanderburgt
Steph Vanderburgt
Aug 28, 2021
Report
Would 10/10 recommend based off their hilarious jokes displayed on their electronic sign which make my day every time I pass by. Thank you for giving me a laugh!
Kyle Thompson
Kyle Thompson
Aug 20, 2021
Report
Meredith the receptionist was to busy to assist with the needs of their clients, referred me back to the broker without even letting me ask my question fully. I was advised "I am working a busy reception desk" this level of customer service is unacceptable.
Pat Babineau
Pat Babineau
Apr 29, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Been dealing with Neil for over 20 years now..... He is an awesome broker he makes it feel like a friend is helping you not just some big insurance company. Fast responses to any questions and concerns we have and any changes in our policies are quick and painless. Thanks again
Sheila Scott
Sheila Scott
Oct 29, 2020
Report
They are quick to answer questions without pushy up selling. Every year we receive a rebate it’s not huge but it’s more than I’ve ever received from any other insurance companies. I have never had a claim so I can’t speak about that aspect.
Dan Claus-Nesbitt
Dan Claus-Nesbitt
Aug 24, 2020
Report
I'm not a customer but I drive by the sign outside every week and I enjoy the dad jokes. Thanks for brightening my commute.
Scott Alischer
Scott Alischer
Mar 01, 2020
Report
Refund!! 😁😁😁
Everyone who works there are awesome and helpful!
Peggy Connor-La Vigne
Peggy Connor-La Vigne
Feb 27, 2020
Report
My family personally and professionally has Ayr Mutual as our Insurance provider. At any chance, I am happy to refer their services to others.
Ashley Smith
Ashley Smith
Jul 22, 2019
Report
The best thing I ever did was switch my car and home insurance to AFM! We've never, ever been given a reason to have a negative word to say about them. Unfortunately, that also includes two claims. One on our home, as well as one accident in our brand new van. Very prompt, professional and friendly. They go so far above and beyond as well.
Jenny Kender
Jenny Kender
Jul 19, 2019
Report
Would Not recommend these people.
I was almost killed by a rogue schoolbus and they were terribly belligerent when I called.
Even the manager I talked to was really nasty.
Not worth the hassle.
Ashley Rose
Ashley Rose
Jun 10, 2019
Report
Can not recommend Ayr Farmers enough! Switched to them when a friend of mine gave me their info, and I am so thankful I did. Got incredible rates, everyone I've ever talked to is so friendly, and even if you have to make a claim, they are still incredible to deal with! Unfortunately dealing with this right now as I was in an accident on Friday and… they have made everything so incredibly easy. Specifically Hannah and Derek M - not at all anything against anyone else, those are just the people I've been dealing with throughout this. Another point worth mentioning and worth a ton of praise
Kristy Perrin
Kristy Perrin
Jun 21, 2018
Report
Ayr Farmers Mutual is an amazing Insurance Company !! We have been with them personally for 15 years our family has been with them well probably since they started !! They go above and beyond and truly Care !! Our agent Ed Down is an amazing agent!! I highly recommend them !!