Papa Joe's Pizzeria
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Papa Joe's Pizzeria
Who is Papa Joe? Papa Joe has been in the pizza business for eighteen years, having owned and operated three successful pizzerias in Waterloo County. Now with three locations to serve you. Olive Oil and Garlic Base, Herbs, Tomato, Red Onion, Italian Sausage, Green Pepper, your choice of cheese. Everyone loves our Rosie!

Everything but the kitchen sink! Calzones are oven-baked - Panzerotti is deep fried. Our flavourful pockets are bursting with our in-house sauce, cheese and the toppings of your choice, Served with a side of Papa's in-house sauce for dipping that wonderful crust, then oven-baked.
Reviews (10)
David Hickman Dsh Cleaning
David Hickman Dsh Cleaning
Dec 29, 2021
Report
Quick and delicious on a cold December night! As a bonus, we stood outside and watched the sunset and the harbour then took in the Port Stanley house lights.
Harlan Cooper
Harlan Cooper
Sep 21, 2021
Report
I had to give 1 star just to be able to post a review. Worst pizza and Calzone ever. The bacon in the Calzone was raw and the Calzone was watery with no cheese. The crust on the pizza was horrible as was the pizza. To top it off the girl cooking the food was unmasked during covid. I can't believe people even eat here.
Richard Elsons
Richard Elsons
Sep 09, 2021
Report
Yummy! First time, my wife and I liked the tasty thin pizza with lot of flavorful toppings. Great chemistry with food and thin crust. Will go again next time. Just 20 minutes away from small town Tillsonburg. Good stuff!!!
Kurt Schuyler
Kurt Schuyler
Aug 21, 2021
Report
You wouldn't think that your food would be so good excellent service friendly maybe could have been a bit cleaner but overall really good pizza don't think it would have been as good as it was. Will go back for sure !!!
Mikayla Harris
Mikayla Harris
Jul 15, 2021
Report
Food was alright, service was awful. pizza was slightly burnt. called at 830 to place a pickup order, was informed that they close in 10 minutes (says 9 online??) and that all their fryers were turned off.. ok fine, disappointing since we wanted wings and poutine but whatever. asked to add garlic butter to my pizza as well as the regular sauce and they told me they can’t do both.. what ? why? girl on the phone was absolutely miserable and also when we got there to pick it up. informed the other worker not to answer the phone when it was ringing, which seems pretty unprofessional to me. overall
Hope Sheeller
Hope Sheeller
Jul 01, 2021
Report
Quality of the food has gone way down. Definitely not fresh cut fries gravy downgraded. Pizzas not what they used to be ...expanding isn't always a good thing I guess.
Christopher Jackson
Christopher Jackson
May 29, 2021
Report
Yes, it's a pizza place that sells pizza. Good pizza though... Not exactly. In the past it's been excellent, but recently, the pizzas have been burnt and just unappealing. There's no consistency and for a pizza joint, I honestly think I could've made a better one on my own (and I'm no cook). It tasted like a pizza that you learn to make in grade 6 and was just flat, burnt, and thin. I even tried calling them a couple times while they were open to order a pizza and finally the next day, someone picked up and I could order. Overall, dissapointing.
Mark T.
Mark T.
Oct 26, 2020
Report
Amazing pizza and poutin. Always enjoy there food. Keep up the awesome work Joe
Mary Ciaramella
Mary Ciaramella
Sep 15, 2020
Report
It’s okay for a last minute pizza . I just find pizza is inconsistent. You ask for not too well done and it’s either over or undercooked . Amount of Toppings are either great or chopped so small you can’t tell one from the other . (Ie red pepper vs sundried tomato). Last time had run out of various meat toppings .. I think a little adult supervision to train for quality would be an improvement . Staff are friendly enough but I still believe some retraining is in order . Fries are awesome !!!
E. J. Kim
E. J. Kim
Jun 02, 2020
Report
I never leave the reviews. Especially I don't like to leave the negative reviews by any means, but this place is just plain awful and people need to be warned. I ordered fish and chips which cost $18 plus tax. I've got this 3 tiny bits of fish and soggy chips. It was so tasteless my dog wouldn't even eat and my dog eats everything. The seagulls enyjoyed them for sure. This was the worst experience I've ever had buying food.