Our staff has the knowledge, experience, equipment and product line to cater to anyone's needs, from a simple tire replacement to a brand new upsize wheel and tire package. Peninsula Tire has the largest selection of used tires in St. Catharines. We carry an inventory of over 5000 used tires and hundreds of new tires. We constantly re-stock our inventory and if, by chance, we do not have a tire size in stock we will gladly order it for you. Ordered tires come in within 24 hours.

Website Update

Services

Services Report

Peninsula Tire proudly carries the largest selection of wheel sizes, makes and designs in St. Catharines. Choose from our in-house inventory of over 5000 used tires and hundreds of new tires, to outfit your vehicle with a customized Tire & Rim package. At Peninsula Tire, we specialize in providing prompt and expert service for tire repairs, for any make and model of vehicle(car & truck).

Reviews (12)

Write a Review

Richard Davis

Jan 19, 2022

Report

Trustworthy people who do a good job. I recently took my truck in for two new tires and some front end work. I had shopped price for the same work elsewhere and it was @20% less expensive. The only hiccup was a mechanic was sick and it took a little longer than expected, but they kept me informed and told the truth which is all you can ask for. I plan to use them again and they are locals not a chain.

Georg M.

Jan 15, 2022

Report

My tire got punched by a screw and start loosing pressure. I called in and could come right away. 20 minutes later I was back on the road with a professional repaired tire.

Jessie Knowles

Nov 19, 2021

Report

Great service - helpful, to the point, and caught a burnt out brake light and replaced it for me while they were putting on my new tires. This is my new tire shop for sure.

Erin Stephens

Nov 13, 2021

Report

Really great experience with this place! I am a home health physical therapist and I need my car to get me to all of my patients' homes. My tire picked up a nail and they met me after hours to drop the car off and had it ready for me first thing in the morning and I wasn't even delayed for my first appointment of the day. Really friendly, quality service! Highly recommend!

Jody Elliott

Oct 13, 2021

Report

I am never disappointed when I come here for service. Everyone is so very friendly and accommodating! The service is great too. I would recommend this place 100% of the time!

B. Young

Oct 01, 2021

Report

Tony is very nice and professional mechanics friendly. They get right to the work to get you on your way safely back on the road reasonable pricing great service. Thankful for recommendations to have service for tires done here!

Maria Pugliese

Aug 30, 2021

Report

I rolled in here at 7:30am opening time Saturday morning with an almost flat tire. I was stressed because I just arrived in town and was scheduled to leave again Sunday morning with a long drive to San Francisco. They tended to me right away, discovered a nail and repaired the tire for only $34! Friendly, fast service. Don't forget to tip your tire guy - they work hard. Highly recommend!

Eric Regnier

Aug 27, 2021

Report

Single best experience I've ever had at a vehicle repair shop!!!
Tony went out of his way to save me money while providing the product I needed in a very timely, convenient fashion.
Thank you!

Nick Souza

Aug 16, 2021

Report

Tony and the guys are always helpful and personable. Tony's shop has serviced all of my families vehicles for over 20 years now and the service at Pen. Tire is the absolute best, with prices that can't be beat. Easily the quickest and best tire repair in the county.

Shaub D.

Mar 31, 2018

Report

This is an old style tire place where they don't nickel and dime you for every thing. I own some high end vehicles and never hesitate to bring them there. Always professionals and friendly.

Coco C.

Jun 07, 2017

Report

Great place! Friendly and ethical with great prices.
Dylan is very sweet. They take care of your car. I'll be returning:)

Demitri P.

Nov 19, 2014

Report

First major snowfall of the year. Place was a madhouse. Still received prompt and courteous care. Good group of people here thumbs up