Guthrie Insurance Brokers
Call now
Call now
Website
Call
Get expert advice and our suggestions for premium savings and the most suitable coverage from leading Canadian Insurers - No Obligation!. Unlike direct insurers or agents, as RIBO licensed, bonded, Brokers we are held legally and professionally accountable to our clients. Expert, thoughtful advice to help you minimize premiums with the most suitable protection.

For over 50 years, the professionals at Guthrie Insurance have been looking after the insurance needs of Ontario families and business in the belief that proper insurance is the cornerstone of financial planning and security. One source to save money, time and have all of your insurance looked after by friendly, dedicated professionals.
Services
For over 50 years, the professionals at Guthrie Insurance have been looking after the insurance needs of Ontario families and businesses in the belief that proper insurance is the cornerstone of financial planning and security. As a 100% Canadian-owned Company, Guthrie Insurance has continued to grow successfully and forge many long-term relationships by combining a unique understanding of our client's needs with thoughtful, expert advice.
At Guthrie Insurance, we recognize that every individual and family is different. One of our personal insurance specialists will help you ensure your policies are properly tailored to suit your specific needs and unique requirements - no overlap of coverage, no gaps, and no gimmicks - just straightforward solutions to everyday situations.
Do you have at least 10 years claims-free driving experience with no more than one conviction in the past 3 years? Are you a conscientious home owner with no claims in the past 10 years? If so, you may be paying for the bad driving habits and poor home maintenance of others! Now get guaranteed savings and superb insurance protection when you combine your automobile and homeowners insurance into one simple package.
You can purchase automobile insurance just about anywhere these days but. Do you really know what you are insured for? Or, what happens to your premium or renewal when you do have an accident, claim, or a ticket? What happens when you really need your policy? Whether you're insuring your family sedan or an exotic luxury car, you will appreciate our experience, our thoughtful advice, and common sense approach.
Your home and personal property is likely your most prized possession, often representing a lifetime worth of hard work and sacrifice. Its loss would be devastating! A properly structured insurance plan will help ease the financial burden of such a tragedy.

Trusting this important protection to the professionals at Guthrie Insurance means you will get caring, thoughtful advice and the right coverage arranged through dependable and financially capable insurance companies.We will review your specific and individual requirements and help you decide on a plan of protection that will help ensure your loss is properly compensated, should you be so unfortunate.
Reviews (10)
Navroz Esmail
Navroz Esmail
Jan 27, 2022
Report
I have been dealing with Jeff Clarkson over at Guthrie Insurance for some time now, and I must say his professionalism and client support is like no other...
I have had dealings with other agents and firms in the past, and these guys set the bar!!!! Extremely pleased with Jeff and Guthrie Insurance!!!!!
Amandeep Vaid
Amandeep Vaid
Oct 26, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Responsiveness
Shaan and Neil we're wonderful - very responsive, thorough, and provided excellent service. They were able to find and secure auto insurance that met all my needs at a very competitive rate within 24 hours. Highly recommended!
Als Double Play
Als Double Play
Oct 01, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism
We have been clients of Guthrie Insurance Brokers for the last five years and are very pleased with the professional service we have received. Our advisor is always prompt and provides sound advice. We are very happy with Guthrie!
Sumedh Kulkarni
Sumedh Kulkarni
Sep 26, 2021
Report
I was preparing to move into a new condo and Shaan from Guthrie Brokers helped me throughout the entire process, from start to finish. He was able to give me excellent coverage and also saved me a sizeable chunk of cash when I paired my auto and condo insurance together. He answered all my questions without any delay and kept me informed on any details I may have missed. Thank you so much, Shaan! I really appreciate your help!
Sonia Malik
Sonia Malik
Jun 01, 2021
Report
I was referred to Guthrie Insurance through a client of mine, Jeff was my direct contact. I bought 2 rentals last year and he was absolutely awesome and the turn around was amazing. This year with my third rental it was also excellent. The response is within the same day, he is efficient and I don't need to worry about any details. He has me covered. So happy with this company :)
Sonia Pak
Sonia Pak
May 10, 2021
Report
Positive: Professionalism, Quality, Responsiveness, Value
Our broker was Agnes Wong. She was tremendous. We were desperate to get coverage when all other companies rejected us outright. But Agnes, determined to save our home and pets, got us two offers!! She's our heroine. We appreciate all her efforts and are so grateful for her assistance.
Eric Malcolmson
Eric Malcolmson
Mar 16, 2021
Report
I am a really badly organized small business owner and Mike Buckley has been a life saver. I've relied on him for a number of policies, he's thorough, responsive and gives excellent advice. Very fast turnaround and response time for both new business and supporting existing policies. I could not recommend his services any more strongly.
David H.
David H.
Jan 10, 2021
Report
We needed business insurance for our small seasonal concrete company and we dealt with Jeff Clarkson and his service was totally outstanding !!!
He got us a policy in a matter of 24 hours.
We will definitely contact Guthrie insurance for our other insurance needs.
I can be a little demanding but Jeff was so efficient and made our experience buying coverage very pleasant and stress free.
I highly recommend Jeff Clarkson for your insurance needs and awesome service .
Robert Skanes
Robert Skanes
Sep 09, 2020
Report
I have been served by Agnes at Guthrie for a number of years now, and cannot recommend her more highly. She has been excellent in responding to my changing insurance needs over time, and most recently was helpful in securing a collection of insurance products for me at a great rate. Do ask for her - you will be pleased with her responsiveness and professionalism.
Ali Sadiq
Ali Sadiq
Jun 23, 2017
Report
Quick, Reliable and accurate. I have used many other online quote generators, but this one has been the most accurate I have seen.